TT Talk - What is piracy?
The concept of piracy has something of a romantic ring to it, with 18th-century rogues such as Captain Kidd, Henry Morgan and others receiving a much more favourable press (not to mention treatment from Hollywood) than they deserve. Many people unconnected with the sea probably think that piracy died out with the age of sail but sadly they are very mistaken.
Modern pirates are still very active and are now armed with an alarming arsenal of automatic weapons, rocket launchers and grenades, as well as swords, scimitars, machetes and knives. There is absolutely nothing romantic about them: they are extremely violent and unscrupulous criminals The International Maritime Bureau reports that last year there were 276 attacks on ships and that 509 seafarers were injured, kidnapped or taken hostage. The waters off Iraq and Somalia have now joined the Malacca straits as areas of high risk.
The High Court of Singapore was recently asked to decide what constituted "piracy" in the context of modern marine insurance practice. A tug had been tied up for the night in the port of Batu Ampar, Batam, Indonesia, when it was attacked by intruders armed with parangs (a kind of machete). The gang severed the mooring ropes and made off with the tug. The owners, Bayswater Carriers Pte Ltd made a claim on their insurers for the insured value, but when they rejected it on the grounds that the loss did not come within the insurance definition of "piracy", Bayswater sued.
The Singapore High Court rejected the insurer's arguments and held that piracy could occur anywhere while the vessel was afloat: it did not have to be on the high seas but could, as in this case, be in port. It was also immaterial whether the ship was moored or anchored.
Interestingly, the court's decision is at variance with article 101 of the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) which defines piracy as a violent act committed for private ends against the crew or passengers of a ship and which occurs on the high seas outside the jurisdiction of any state. Technically therefore, an attack within a harbour area would constitute "armed robbery" rather than "piracy", although such fine legal distinctions would probably be lost on the majority of victims.
A free download copy of the IMB's report on pirate incidents in 2005 can be obtained from http://www.icc-ccs.org/main/publication.php
Fuller details and analysis of the Bayswater Carriers case can be read on David Martin-Clark's website DMC's CaseNotes at:http://archive.onlinedmc.co.uk/bayswater_carriers_v__qbe_insurance.htm
You may also be interested in:
The forum, held via an interactive webinar entitled 'Drones and autonomous vehicles: The future. now?', presented the current advances in autonomous transport in the air, at sea and on land. It examined the benefits and limitations of the technologies as well as the accelerating effects on adoption within international supply chains brought about by the current crisis.
TT Talk - Legal eagle: know the shipper
This judgment sets out a useful analysis of contracts where a court will examine the conduct of the parties and surrounding circumstances to reach a conclusion. Carriers should be alerted to the importance of knowing who they are dealing with, ensuring that the shipper on a bill of lading is correctly identified.