TT Talk - Attempts by shippers to use bills of lading for fraudulent purposes
A shipper purchases goods in country A with the intention of exporting them to country B. Due to import restrictions in country B on goods from country A, the shipper wants to declare that the origin of the goods is not country A, but instead country C. He is looking to find a carrier who would falsely name a port in country C as 'Port of loading'. Based on this false information, the shipper would then obtain a certificate of origin with Country C named as 'Country of origin'.
Another shipper requests the carriage of goods from country A to country B, with the shipper's subsidiary in country C named as 'Shipper'. Country B grants tax concessions to imports from country A. The shipper, attempting to take advantage of these tax concessions, requests the carrier to produce for the same consignment an extra bill of lading which names the shipper's subsidiary in country A as 'Shipper'. This extra bill of lading is not being used in the commercial dealing between the parties; its sole purpose is to enable the shipper to obtain a certificate of origin based on which country B grants him the tax concessions.
In both these cases the shipper requires the carrier to include false information in the bills of lading which then enables the shipper to use the bill of lading for fraudulent purposes. The
shipper might tell the carrier that other carriers have been willing to comply with such requests, implying that the carrier will lose out on business if he fails to collaborate. You will be aware that giving in to such requests could make the carrier party to the shipper's fraudulent conduct in which case the carrier risks heavy fines, blacklisting and criminal proceedings. A letter of indemnity by the shipper in the carrier's favour might well be unenforceable due to its underlying purpose and will be of no use to the carrier in the criminal proceedings. The Club (in common with most liability insurers) will not cover any claims, fines or defence costs you suffer owing to your intentional or reckless conduct
You may also be interested in:
The recent severing of diplomatic ties with Qatar by several countries (the "Alliance Countries") is having a knock on effect on trade between Qatar and the Alliance Countries, and also an impact on the international carriage of goods to or from Qatar.
TT Talk - Legal eagle: packages & contracts
Recent caselaw suggests that English courts will lean towards the selecting interpretations on limits of liability that favour a claimant. Unwelcome to the carrier community, so worth considering how best to describe goods on carriage documents.
While there may be valid trading reasons that give rise to bill of lading difficulties, there is an unhealthy under-belly of criminal activity.
Recent case law from the NSW Court of Appeal in Australia acts as a reminder to freight forwarders to consider carefully the question of ‘whether to issue a house bill of lading?’ for a consignment. When doing so, there are clear steps to take to protect the rights of all stakeholders and avoid unforeseen exposures.